Re: Magpie has rights too, judge rules

On Thu, 3 Jul 2003 13:53:14 +0100, "Jill"
<news@REMOVETHISkintaline.plus.com> wrote:

>
>"Malcolm" <MAO@indaal.demon.co.uk> wrote in message
>news:TjwKkUhOgBB$EwdP@indaal.demon.co.uk...
>>
>> In article <PKfLPiXsi9A$EwV$@clef.demon.co.uk>, Charles Francis
>> <charles@clef.demon.co.uk> writes
>> >In message <428df4d53112eefebef732e48018ba4f@free.teranews.co m>,
>> >Malcolm <Malcolm@malcsplace.com> writes
>> >>There has never been a case of corvids killing a healthy animal on the
>> >>farm, despite your misrepresentation, the same act you use to justify
>> >>killing foxes by your hunt friends.
>> >>
>> >>Get real,
>> >
>> >
>> >Get real yourself. Magpies and carrion crows take ducklings, chicks and
>> >even goslings, quite apart from eggs, and decimate wildlife
>> >populations. And its not just one or two, they decimate populations.
>>
>> For which last statement, I would ask you to produce some hard evidence.
>
>you really need to get into the real world
>They will take whole clutches in the space of less than an hour
>that is pretty good decimation in anyones book

Is this one clutch or hundreds and thousands of clutches? (es!!)

>often however they take them over a period of days

Ah that must be why there is no substance on record for your story,
crafty these mags arent they?

>the result is the same
>nothing to go into the next generation

You need to get out more.

>>
>> Hint: there isn't any and it is a subject that has been investigated in
>> depth.
>> A few anecdotes, mostly in letters to the Telegraph, but nothing more.
>
>You ask anyone who lives in the real world and they will not have anecdotes
>but first hand experience
>IE - they have seen it happen time and again

Once, twice, maybe even three times in a lifetime.

No doubt you have larsen trap in hand to save the world?

--

So, you dont like reasoned,
well thought out, civil debate?

I understand.

/´¯/)
/¯../
/..../
/´¯/'...'/´¯¯`·¸
/'/.../..../......./¨¯\
('(...´...´.... ¯~/'...')
\.................'...../
''...\.......... _.·´
\..............(
\.............\..

	#1
Malcolm	Re: Magpie has rights too, judge rules On Thu, 3 Jul 2003 13:53:14 +0100, "Jill" <news@REMOVETHISkintaline.plus.com> wrote: > >"Malcolm" <MAO@indaal.demon.co.uk> wrote in message >news:TjwKkUhOgBB$EwdP@indaal.demon.co.uk... >> >> In article <PKfLPiXsi9A$EwV$@clef.demon.co.uk>, Charles Francis >> <charles@clef.demon.co.uk> writes >> >In message <428df4d53112eefebef732e48018ba4f@free.teranews.co m>, >> >Malcolm <Malcolm@malcsplace.com> writes >> >>There has never been a case of corvids killing a healthy animal on the >> >>farm, despite your misrepresentation, the same act you use to justify >> >>killing foxes by your hunt friends. >> >> >> >>Get real, >> > >> > >> >Get real yourself. Magpies and carrion crows take ducklings, chicks and >> >even goslings, quite apart from eggs, and decimate wildlife >> >populations. And its not just one or two, they decimate populations. >> >> For which last statement, I would ask you to produce some hard evidence. > >you really need to get into the real world >They will take whole clutches in the space of less than an hour >that is pretty good decimation in anyones book Is this one clutch or hundreds and thousands of clutches? (es!!) >often however they take them over a period of days Ah that must be why there is no substance on record for your story, crafty these mags arent they? >the result is the same >nothing to go into the next generation You need to get out more. >> >> Hint: there isn't any and it is a subject that has been investigated in >> depth. >> A few anecdotes, mostly in letters to the Telegraph, but nothing more. > >You ask anyone who lives in the real world and they will not have anecdotes >but first hand experience >IE - they have seen it happen time and again Once, twice, maybe even three times in a lifetime. No doubt you have larsen trap in hand to save the world? -- So, you dont like reasoned, well thought out, civil debate? I understand. /´¯/) /¯../ /..../ /´¯/'...'/´¯¯`·¸ /'/.../..../......./¨¯\ ('(...´...´.... ¯~/'...') \.................'...../ ''...\.......... _.·´ \..............( \.............\..